Dotneteers.net
All for .net, .net for all!

Windows Phone Start Screen Wastes Tons of Screen Real Estate. Or does it?

VBandi's blog

Syndication

Subscribe

Generic Content

One of the things people say when looking at the Windows Phone Start Screen is that it wastes a lot of Screen Real Estate on the right side.  Here is what I am talking about:

image

See? The right side is occupied by just a black space with an arrow. “That space could and should be used to display useful information!”

One of the reasons for the space on the right side is that if you move the tiles up, the clock doesn’t get obscured:

image

But still, I hear you say… “There is so much wasted space there!” OK, I’ll play along. What if we enlarge the tiles and don’t care about the clock?

imageimage

See? Compared to the original version, we actually have less information on the screen, despite starting a bit higher up. If I remove the margin entirely, things are even worse:

image

No whitespace, just a lot of valuable content. Right? But where did the Photo Hub’s tile go? Barely visible, just a few pixels here. And how much value did we get? We can put a few more characters in the tiles without changing the font size, but nothing to call home about.

OK, but if we do utilize the entire screen, we may be able to put three columns of tiles there, right?

image

Maybe… these tiles are 152 pixels wide, maybe 10% drop from the current 173. But the fonts on the tiles are getting too small to read easily if you are beyond your twenties… What do you think? Does being able to see the extra 5-6 tile worth it? I personally prefer the current, two column layout, three columns just feel crowded. Maybe if I had a bigger phone and bigger resolution, additional columns would make sense…


Posted Mar 23 2012, 04:17 PM by vbandi

Comments

Matthijs Krempel wrote re: Windows Phone Start Screen Wastes Tons of Screen Real Estate. Or does it?
on Fri, Mar 23 2012 16:27

I don't agree,.

I can use 173x173 tiles in my apps aswell, they are the ideal fit for a panorama control. So, the size of the tiles can stay consistent troughout the entire phone!

That's more important then a few wasted pixels.

Russell Gilbert wrote re: Windows Phone Start Screen Wastes Tons of Screen Real Estate. Or does it?
on Fri, Mar 23 2012 16:30

Maybe we could have a little bar at the top with the Carrier name, a Signal strength metre, the time and a battery Guage.

Then we could have 4 rows of Icons for the apps that we could swipe from side to side for different pages a 5th row in a kind of dock at the bottom. Then maybe we could forget about the live tiles and just put little red alerts wth a number in on the tiles (# of unread emails, #number updates etc).

Then maybe if you swipe all the way over to the left we could have a search page. Finally we could just have one big button at the bottom.

Would that work?

vbandi wrote re: Windows Phone Start Screen Wastes Tons of Screen Real Estate. Or does it?
on Fri, Mar 23 2012 16:35

Russel: lol :)

PHenry wrote re: Windows Phone Start Screen Wastes Tons of Screen Real Estate. Or does it?
on Fri, Mar 23 2012 16:38

OH wow!  I actually like the three wide now that you show it up there!  Nice.

Mary Branscombe wrote re: Windows Phone Start Screen Wastes Tons of Screen Real Estate. Or does it?
on Fri, Mar 23 2012 16:40

man, that three tile grid is ugly and hard to read ;-)

Community Blogs wrote Windows Dev News for March 23, 2012 - #0056
on Sat, Mar 24 2012 6:27

Windows Dev News for March 23, 2012 - #0056 [SC1232] In This Issue: Sumit Dutta ( -2- ), Heather Brown

Alex wrote re: Windows Phone Start Screen Wastes Tons of Screen Real Estate. Or does it?
on Thu, Apr 19 2012 1:20

before WP I used iPhone and it has 4 columns and even smaller font and I loved it. I would want WP to have 3 or 4 columns, this way I could just tap on more apps right there without scrolling. The tiles are waisting space anyways, they can be reduced without sacraficing the font size (am I the only one who can see this?). Also, the text is only for new users, let's face it, once you know your phone, you don't read each tile, you just go by the picture/icon, so who cares about the text. have you also seen the front screen that has the tiny icons with number of text, voice and email messages? well if you can see that, than you surely could go for smaller tiles. What about battery, you can see that, right? and it is tiny. So, don't be like "i can't see it, I am too old", get glasses or eye contacts and you will be fine.